Filing a Claim
For your convenience, provided below are links to the companies that allow online claims service or the companies contacts web page. Also provided are the phone numbers for each of the companies. After filing a claim with the company, please contact our office so we can follow up on your claim and make sure it is handled to your expectations and satisfaction. Please find our contact information on our "Contacts" page. If you looking to email a particular person, you can find our email addresses on our "About" page, click on "Our Staff."
Company Number
21st Century 1-800-322-8200
Chartis Refer to website for appropriate number
Encompass 1-800-588-7400
Erie and Niagara 716-632-5433
Farmers 1-800-435-7764
Foremost 1-800-527-3907
GMAC 1-800-325-1088
Hereford 718.361.9191 Extension 7154
(compensation claims)

718.361.1221 Extension 7201
(commercial liability claims)
Hagerty 1-800-922-4050
Kemper 1–888–252–2799
Midstate Mutual 1-800-826-8520
(After hours claims numbers found on website)
The Main Street America Group 1-877-425-2467
New York Mutual Underwriters 1-800-962-3155
New York State Insurance Fund refer to website for appropriate number
Progressive 1-800-274-4499
Security Mutual refer to website for appropriate website
Travelers 1-800-252-4633 (auto, home, personal property)
1-800-238-6225 (Business)
Zurich 1-800-987-3373